WAY MORE WEST:
Edward Dorn as Literary Heretic
Vernon Frazer
In WAY MORE WEST, editor Michael Rothenberg has compiled a selection of poems that portray Edward Dorn as a poet more complex than the sum of his Black Mountain parts. While Black Mountain inspired and educated him, Dorn expanded his work into areas outside its scope. His incorporation of typography (Gunslinger), concrete poetry (“Mesozoic Landscape”), and multiple-voiced text (Languedoc Variorum) placed him in a camp of his own, in which his abstract devices expressed his social concerns in a tone that grew increasingly activist with age. As his style evolved, it incorporated foreign languages, regional dialects, word play and a sense of place that synthesized into a voice more projecting than projectivist in its command of craft and presence. Dorn’s Protestantism, simply an accident of birth in 1930 America, emerged as a force in his later work to the extent that Dorn positioned himself as a social and literary heretic so that he could articulate dissenting views rooted as deep in history as Martin Luther’s break with the Catholic Church, and the Spanish and English colonization of the Americas. Dorn is one of the few American poets whose work draws cogent comparisons between historic and contemporary events.
If Dorn’s Black Mountain influence was evident in his Creeleyesque
use of rhyme
why don’t you feed them? I ventured.
She said she wasn’t indentured. [5]
so were his senses of satiric humor and social justice, as well as his underlying pessimism (even in everyday events such as the one hinted at in “The Rick of Green Wood”:
in the november
air, in the world, that was getting colder
as we stood there in the woodyard talking
pleasantly. . . ) [2]
as well as an incisive self-awareness, first described in The Newly Fallen as “the great geography of my lunacy.” [13] Dorn, the Black Mountain child, was father to the stand-alone man whose craft and social protest evolved from
the breadlines of the deprived are here
Los Alamos 1960, not Salinas
not Stockton. [16]
to the “Rough Passage on I-80” on which
the Prontosauris Oil Company
sits next to the Horny-Toed Boot Factory [215]
while its punning neologisms keep militant pace with the encroachment of international corporations on America’s heartland.
But Dorn’s sense of place wasn’t always physical, as Gunslinger indicates. The Slinger’s trip to Las Vegas runs
Across
two states
of mind, saith the Horse. [121]
Geographic place, so central to Dorn’s work, expands In this innovative longpoem, which absorbs and projects the free-wheeling spirit of the sixties into literary form. Place, other than the generalized location of the West, loses its literalness as Dorn transposes the Gunslinger myth of pulp novels, radio, movies and early televison into an elevated reality, part mocking and part metaphysical. The poem’s characters include a semidios Gunslinger who lives outside the boundaries of time, a talking horse named after two postmodern philosophers, and a character named “I” whose style and destiny Dorn uses to overturn the conventions of viewpoint from the opening lines
I met in Mesilla
The Cautious Gunslinger [91]
in which “I” can either be the first-person narrator or the subject of a third-person narration. Undermining the conventions of narrative enables Dorn to extend reality beyond the period’s post-naturalistic realism into Gunslinger’s multi-leveled reality, which surfaced concurrently with The Wild, Wild West televison show and anticipated such satires of the Western genre as Ishmael Reed’s Yellowback Radio Broke-Down.
In Book I, the bold, enlarged font of the guitar “strum” establishes a musical and visual presence that helps lift the work off the page. Visually, the “strum” marks dramatic pauses in a narrative that could as easily fit a television screen as a pulp novel.
In subsequent works, Dorn’s return to a less rarefied atmosphere allowed him to explore the theme of love that threaded through his earlier works. Twenty-Four Love Songs blends intimacy and metaphysics in ways that render them part of the same continuum:
My speech is tinged
my tongue has taken
a foreigner into it
Can you understand
my uncertainties grow
and underbrush and thicket
of furious sensibility
between us and wholly
unlike the marvelously burning
bush which lies at the entrance
to your gated thighs
My dear love, when I unsheathe
a word of the wrong temper
it is to test that steel
across the plain between us [126]
If Gunslinger remains Dorn’s magnum opus, Twenty-four Love Songs reveals his more intimate side while its topical poems continue the thread of his social commentary. But the selections from Abhorrences: a Chronicle of the Eighties reveal the book as a pivotal work in Dorn’s career. In Abhorrences, Dorn’s underlying Protestantism finds full expression.
The Protestant View:
that eternal dissent
and the ravages of
faction are preferable
to the voluntary
servitude of blind
obedience.
In this poem, Dorn virtually lays out his future role as a poet: a dissenter and heretic in the tradition of Martin Luther separating from the Catholic Church. Dorn assumes the heretic mantle for much of his later work, including Westward Haut and Languedoc Variorum, two works that would have rivaled and possibly surpassed Gunslinger in their scope, ambition and achievement, had he lived to complete them.
“Rough Stretch on I-80” from Abhorrences employs a heightened sense of place that differs from the realism of “Idaho Out” and the near-psychedelic sense of location of Gunslinger. Its satiric tone and acidic neologisms caricature the world of commercialism that has consumed locations such as I-80, once a somewhat pristine route through America’s heartland. But the running documentary of rampantly spreading commercialism in “Rough Passage on I-80” concludes with
Martyrs are a dime a dozen around here.
The best ones have been dead a long time. [217]
which suggests that the voice filling the poem with images of protest knowingly risks becoming a martyr for protesting the “religion of capitalism” and the other orthodoxies contributing to the creation and development of the rough passage. Dorn implies that he intends to be one of “the best ones” and that he knows the consequences he will endure because of the increasing element of protest in his work.
Westward Haut continues and builds on the satiric elements of “Rough Stretch on I-80”. Odin, a god cast in canine form (god=dog), while flying from Peru to Cheyenne, draws parallels between the brutal Spanish and British colonization of the Americas in the sixteenth century and the relation between 1990s terrorism and business practices in “an assembly of images awash in avarice.” Odin, “a dog of Judgment,” explains the ways of god to dog in relation to the “homocorps,” a word that employs the implied pejorative overtones of “homosexual” to further diminish the stature of human beings who, in canine discourse, could appropriately be called “homocorps” as in “homo” from homo sapiens” and “corps” as a mass population, the group primarily affected by the god/dog’s world view of business. The view seems uncannily prescient:
Business is a form of terror— you leave the victim,
the customer, even the mere low-end shopper wasted,
drained of cash and will and shackled to the future—
wage slaves of cash and will shackled to the future
wage-slaves of les Rentiers.
The difference is you don’t kill’em,
you just pillage the village—
it’s a license operation. [241]
If Westward Haut consolidates Dorn’s singular blend of literary techniques and heightens his sense of place, Languedoc Variorum: a Defense of Heresy and Heretics features Dorn assuming the heretic stance as he rages against the Crusades, particularly the Albigensian Crusade against the heretical Cathars of Languedoc, and draws analogies to the political activities of the 1990s, using a multi-voiced approach that finds ready counterparts in televison news broadcasting and contrapuntal music. Dorn divides the page into three sections. The poem per se appears in the top third of the page. In a news broadcast, it would appear as the anchor speaking. In a musical performance, it would appear as the central melodic line. What Dorn calls “SUBTEXTS & NAZDAKS” occupy the center and bottom thirds of the page. The subtexts underscore the text with present-day commentaries. “Jerusalem,” for example, links the brutality the Christians inflicted on Moslems and Jews in the First Crusade to contemporary acts of murder and genocide:
The savagery was Ruandan and Ugandan. [267]
The subtexts function as sidebar commentaries or counter-melodic lines, offering religious and historical commentary that supports the heretic stance against the Crusades and contemporary war
¶ Looking back over the tyranny of Rome and Constantinople,
heresy is the only honorable mode and response. [266]
and mocking the media’s priorities, such as broadcasting Ted Kennedy mixing dust from his brothers’ graves with the soil of the late Prime Minister Rabin’s grave while a disaster in the Philippines goes virtually ignored. The nazdaks function like a running subtitle, updating the news moment by moment, or serving as a third contrapuntal line:
gender fascism up 90%, investment in pogrom for euroamerican
males– academic marxists steady entrenched pricing– repression
of the market in standard works–nazdaq plunges, literature
forced into bankruptcy–burghers of theory replace samurais
of literature– . [270]
Dorn blurs the line between poem and commentary by running his subtexts and nazdaks through five poems, establishing a thread of continuity through the acts of the heretics portrayed, not only stressing the need to criticize the existing powers but also pointing toward a redefinition of what constitutes a poem.
The heretical statements that follow the multi-leveled “Languedoc Variorum” demonstrate the continued need for heretics because, as Dorn points out,
. . . the Lutheran Prize for Literature announced in Stockholm
predicably went to an Irishman of the Roman faith...
which suggests that Luther’s break with the Catholic Church ultimately followed the path of many political rebellions, in which the rebel ultimately re-assimilates with the institution rebelled against. If this is the case, then, in Dorn’s view, the heretics are those who, at great risk to themselves, kept the world “honest.”
Honesty is the key to Chemo Sabe, Dorn’s last published work, in which he knowingly lays down his last pieces of wisdom. The title resonates with meanings, starting with Kemosabe from the Lone Ranger, at once suggesting a kind of gallows humor and the intimacy, however grim, that a Cancer patient develops with the drug of survival during chemotherapy. If interpreted as “Chemo Knows,” the title suggests the poems contain the terminal awareness that one develops from staring death in the eye on a daily basis, as Dorn implies during “Infusion Day”:
the measure of the mystery of what
remains the life and times
of the victim, condemned but not delivered,
just the keeper of the count, slowly
joining the counter. [306]
“White Rabbit” gives a graphic account of getting blood drawn. In describing his reactions, he offers, after a fashion, a summary of his life:
as usual, my tongue has been
my genius and my downfall. [313]
Although some of the poems in Chemo Sabe continue to rage against social injustice, Dorn’s final poem of his lifetime shows the humility of his final awareness:
The Garden of the White Rose
Lord, your mercy is stretched so thin
to accommodate the need
of the trembling earth—
How can I solicit even
a particle of it
for the relief of my singularity
the single White Rose
across the garden will
return next year
identical to your faith —
the White Rose, whose
house is light against the
threatening darkness. [317]
In the moments before dying, Dorn, ever the heretic railing against the orthodoxy of his time, returned to the humility at the core of his Protestant roots. A poet whose authorial voice was so strong he could virtually “hold court” over his audience from the printed page, Dorn softened his tone to private prayer while gaining perspective on his humble place in the universe.
Dorn’s work represents his own personal and poetic evolution, and his statements, both strident and loving, evolved in the manner of his work, developing in the Black Mountain environment but evolving into modes of address that rendered him an American Original. While providing a valuable introduction to his work, WAY MORE WEST attests to Dorn’s stature as one of the most powerful and unique voices in American poetry.
WAY MORE WEST: New and Selected Poems by Edward Dorn. Edited by Michael Rothenberg. Penguin Books, 2007. ISBN: 978-0-14-303689-6. $20.00. Paper,
:: HOME :: CURRENT ISSUE :: MASTHEAD :: SUBSCRIBE :: PAST ISSUES ::
:: SUBMISSIONS :: ADVERTISING :: RESOURCES :: DISTRIBUTION ::